On May 27, 1957, Brunswick Records released a single credited to a young Texas group called the Crickets. The title was “That’ll Be the Day,” and although the musicians could not have known it at the time, the record would become one of the foundational recordings of early rock and roll.
At the microphone was Buddy Holly, a 20-year-old singer and guitarist from Lubbock, Texas, whose previous attempts at breaking into the record business had produced little success. Beside him were musicians who would help establish one of rock’s most enduring band formats: guitar, rhythm guitar, bass, and drums.
The song was short, direct, rhythmic, and remarkably confident. Holly’s distinctive vocal hiccup gave it personality, while the Crickets supplied a lean instrumental sound that seemed to contain almost nothing unnecessary. There was no enormous orchestra, no elaborate studio spectacle, and no attempt to soften the performance into conventional pop.
It sounded like a band.
Within months, “That’ll Be the Day” had reached No. 1 in the United States and the United Kingdom, transforming Buddy Holly and the Crickets into international stars. The recording would influence the Beatles and generations of guitar groups that followed, enter the GRAMMY Hall of Fame, and eventually be selected for preservation in the Library of Congress National Recording Registry.
Remarkably, however, this wasn’t even Buddy Holly’s first recording of the song.
The first version had failed.
🎬 It Started With John Wayne
The title “That’ll Be the Day” came from an unexpected source: John Wayne.
In May 1956, Buddy Holly, drummer Jerry Allison, and musician Sonny Curtis went to see John Ford’s Western The Searchers at a theater in Lubbock.
Wayne plays Ethan Edwards, a Civil War veteran engaged in a long and increasingly obsessive search for his abducted niece. During the film, his character repeatedly uses the expression “that’ll be the day” as a dismissive response to something he does not believe will happen.
The line stuck with Holly and Allison.
According to Allison’s later recollection, the two were talking a few days after seeing the film when Holly suggested they write a song. Allison jokingly repeated Wayne’s expression.
Holly immediately recognized its potential.
A movie catchphrase had become a song title.
✍️ Buddy Holly the Songwriter
One of the things that distinguished Holly from many pop performers of his era was that he increasingly wrote his own material.
The separation between singer and songwriter was common during the 1950s. Professional composers might write a song, publishers would promote it, and several singers might record competing versions.
Holly belonged to a different tradition.
He played guitar.
He wrote songs.
He performed them with a band.
He participated in arranging and recording them.
That combination would become completely normal for rock groups during the 1960s, but it was still important enough in 1957 to make Holly unusual.
Accounts of the creation of “That’ll Be the Day” center on Holly and Jerry Allison, who developed the song together soon after seeing The Searchers. The released record also carried a songwriting credit for producer Norman Petty, a practice connected with several Holly compositions from the period.
The song itself came together quickly.
The difficult part was getting anyone to recognize how good it was.
🎙️ The First “That’ll Be the Day”
Buddy Holly had already attracted the attention of Decca Records after opening shows for artists including Elvis Presley.
Decca sent him to Nashville, where producer Owen Bradley attempted to shape the young Texan into a country performer.
On July 22, 1956, Holly recorded the first version of “That’ll Be the Day.”
It was not the record that later became famous.
The Nashville recording leaned more heavily toward country and western music and lacked some of the driving quality that would characterize the later version.
The sessions also placed Holly in an uncomfortable position creatively. Rather than recording with complete control over his own band and sound, he was working within Nashville’s established studio system.
The relationship with Decca ultimately failed.
His singles did not become hits, and the company declined to renew his contract.
For many aspiring musicians, that might have been the end of the story.
For Holly, it became an opportunity to try the song again.
🚗 From Lubbock to Clovis
About 100 miles west of Lubbock lay Clovis, New Mexico, where producer and recording engineer Norman Petty operated a studio.
The location was far removed from the major American recording centers of New York, Los Angeles, Nashville, Chicago, and Memphis.
That distance became an advantage.
Petty’s studio provided Holly and his musicians with something they had lacked in Nashville: time and freedom to develop their own sound.
Instead of adapting themselves to someone else’s idea of what a country singer should be, they could experiment.
Holly began making repeated trips from Texas to Clovis.
The combination of his songwriting, his band, and Petty’s studio would produce one of the most remarkable bursts of creativity in early rock and roll.
🌨️ Recording the Hit Version
In late February 1957, Holly and his musicians returned to “That’ll Be the Day.”
This time, the result was completely different.
The session included Holly on lead vocal and guitar, Jerry Allison on drums, Niki Sullivan on rhythm guitar, and bassist Larry Welborn, who was filling the bass role before Joe B. Mauldin became the regular Cricket. Background vocalists added another layer to the recording.
The hit version reportedly required only two takes.
Compared with the earlier Nashville recording, the new performance was leaner, lower in pitch, and much more firmly rooted in rock and roll.
The beat had more momentum.
The guitars were clearer.
Holly sounded more confident.
Instead of sounding like a young performer being fitted into an existing musical category, he sounded like himself.
That difference changed everything.
🥁 The Texas Shuffle
The rhythm of “That’ll Be the Day” contributes enormously to its character.
The Library of Congress has described the recording’s drive as a form of Texas shuffle, bringing together elements of country, rhythm and blues, and the rapidly emerging language of rock and roll.
Jerry Allison’s drumming gives the record a relaxed but persistent movement. The rhythm never feels heavy, yet it continually pushes the song forward.
Holly’s guitar fits into that groove rather than dominating it.
The result is one of the qualities that makes the recording sound surprisingly modern.
Nothing seems overcrowded.
Every instrument has room.
The record breathes.
🎸 A Different Kind of Rock Star
Buddy Holly did not look like the most obvious candidate to become a rock-and-roll idol.
Elvis Presley projected danger and sexuality.
Little Richard seemed almost explosively theatrical.
Jerry Lee Lewis attacked a piano like he was trying to destroy it.
Buddy Holly wore glasses.
His stage appearance could seem almost ordinary.
Yet that ordinary quality became revolutionary in its own way.
Holly suggested that rock and roll did not require becoming an exotic character. A young person with a guitar could write songs, form a band with friends, and make records.
For countless teenagers watching from Britain and America, that possibility may have been even more inspiring than unattainable movie-star glamour.
He looked like someone who might go to your school.
Then he plugged in a Fender Stratocaster.
🦗 Becoming the Crickets
There was still a serious problem after the recording was completed.
Holly had recently been under contract with Decca, and contractual restrictions complicated the possibility of simply releasing the new recording under his own name.
Norman Petty helped devise a solution.
The recording could be marketed under the name of a group.
The musicians began searching for an appropriate band name and eventually settled on the Crickets.
The name followed a tradition of vocal and R&B groups using animal names, but it also possessed the sort of simple memorability that suited the band.
The Crickets eventually solidified around Holly, Jerry Allison, bassist Joe B. Mauldin, and rhythm guitarist Niki Sullivan.
More important than the exact personnel at any particular session was the structure they presented.
Lead guitar and vocals.
Rhythm guitar.
Bass.
Drums.
It would soon become one of the standard configurations of rock music.
💿 Brunswick Takes a Chance
Norman Petty brought the recording east and attempted to find a label willing to release it.
Several record executives reportedly passed.
Eventually, Bob Thiele at Coral Records heard the recording and believed in it.
Coral belonged to the same corporate family as Decca, and the situation surrounding Holly’s earlier contract was complicated. The solution was to place the Crickets recording on Brunswick Records, another Decca-affiliated label.
The single was assigned catalog number 9-55009.
On one side was “That’ll Be the Day.”
On the other was “I’m Lookin’ for Someone to Love.”
The label credited the performer simply as The Crickets.
Buddy Holly’s name did not appear prominently as the artist.
That anonymity would not last long.
📅 May 27, 1957
Brunswick released “That’ll Be the Day” on May 27, 1957.
There was no immediate indication that history had just entered the record stores.
According to the Library of Congress account, the initial pressing consisted of only about 1,000 copies.
Even Billboard did not recognize a future classic. Its initial assessment was relatively unenthusiastic.
The record’s success developed slowly.
That makes the story more interesting.
“This is obviously a masterpiece” was not the industry’s first reaction.
Listeners had to prove it.
📻 Radio Builds the Hit
Local and regional radio play gradually pushed “That’ll Be the Day” forward.
Disc jockeys in cities including Philadelphia and Buffalo gave the record substantial exposure, and demand began spreading.
This was how many early rock-and-roll records succeeded.
National television appearances could help enormously, but regional radio remained capable of transforming a relatively obscure single into a phenomenon.
Young listeners heard something they liked.
They requested it.
Record shops sold copies.
More stations added it.
The pattern repeated from city to city.
By late July, Billboard had changed its attitude and identified the record as a strong seller.
Two months later, the song reached the top.
🥇 No. 1 in America
On September 23, 1957, “That’ll Be the Day” reached No. 1 on Billboard’s popular music chart.
It had taken nearly four months from its release to reach the top.
The climb transformed the lives of Holly and the Crickets almost overnight.
They were suddenly touring nationally, appearing on television, meeting other stars, and being asked for follow-up records.
Holly had gone from losing his Nashville record contract to becoming one of the biggest new performers in American rock and roll.
The song that had failed in its first incarnation had become his breakthrough.
The difference was not the basic composition.
It was the performance.
🇬🇧 Britain Hears Buddy Holly
The record’s impact extended well beyond the United States.
“That’ll Be the Day” reached No. 1 on the UK singles chart, where it remained at the top for three weeks.
Its British success would become particularly important because a generation of young British musicians was listening closely.
Buddy Holly was enormously influential in Britain.
His use of guitars, his songwriting, his approachable appearance, and the idea of a self-contained rock group proved deeply attractive to teenagers who would soon create the British rock boom of the 1960s.
Among those listeners were young musicians in Liverpool.
🎸 The Quarrymen Record Buddy Holly
Before there was a Beatles record, there was a Buddy Holly song.
In 1958, the Quarrymen—the group that included John Lennon, Paul McCartney, and George Harrison and eventually evolved into the Beatles—made an amateur recording of “That’ll Be the Day.”
The choice speaks volumes.
Holly represented a model young British musicians could imagine following.
He wrote material.
He played guitar.
He sang.
He worked with a small band.
The very name Beatles would later echo the insect-based naming style associated with the Crickets, although several influences and wordplay contributed to the eventual name.
Holly’s impact on the emerging British beat-group culture was enormous even though his own international career lasted only a remarkably short time.
🎼 A Band That Wrote Its Own Songs
One of the most consequential aspects of Buddy Holly and the Crickets was their songwriting.
Many successful singers of the 1950s relied heavily upon outside writers.
Holly and his circle increasingly created their own material.
“That’ll Be the Day” therefore pointed toward the model that would become central to rock during the 1960s.
The Beatles wrote Lennon-McCartney songs.
The Rolling Stones developed Jagger-Richards.
The Beach Boys had Brian Wilson.
Rock increasingly became associated not merely with interpreting songs but with bands generating their own repertoire.
Holly did not invent that idea by himself, but he helped demonstrate its power within rock and roll.
🎛️ The Studio as a Creative Space
Holly’s work with Norman Petty also helped establish another important idea.
A recording studio did not need to be a place where musicians simply documented the way they sounded onstage.
It could become part of the creative process.
Holly experimented with overdubbing, vocal layering, instrumental textures, percussion, and other recording techniques during his short career.
Later records would push those experiments considerably further.
But “That’ll Be the Day” already demonstrates careful attention to sound.
The recording is clean enough for individual instrumental parts to remain distinct.
The vocal sits clearly at the center.
Background voices add color without overwhelming the track.
The band sounds immediate rather than distant.
The studio helped turn four young musicians into something larger than the sum of their instruments.
🎤 That Famous Vocal Style
Buddy Holly’s voice was impossible to mistake.
He stretched words.
He jumped unexpectedly between notes.
He inserted the little vocal catches and hiccups that became one of his signatures.
None of this sounded like traditional polished pop singing.
That was exactly why it worked.
Rock and roll valued personality.
A singer did not necessarily need the smoothest or most powerful voice.
The voice needed to be recognizable.
Holly’s was.
Within a few seconds of “That’ll Be the Day,” the listener knows who is singing.
🎶 Simple Doesn’t Mean Easy
Part of the song’s brilliance lies in how little it appears to require.
The structure is straightforward.
The melody is immediately memorable.
The instrumental arrangement is economical.
The performance does not sound strained.
Yet simplicity can be difficult to achieve.
A cluttered arrangement would have weakened the rhythm.
A more theatrical vocal might have made the song sound forced.
A longer performance could have diluted its impact.
The recording lasts only a little over two minutes.
It arrives, makes its point, and leaves.
That economy became one of the great strengths of early rock-and-roll singles.
📀 The “Chirping” Crickets
The success of “That’ll Be the Day” led to more Crickets recordings and eventually the album The “Chirping” Crickets, released later in 1957.
The album contained “That’ll Be the Day” alongside records including “Oh, Boy!,” “Not Fade Away,” and “Maybe Baby.”
Taken together, these recordings reveal how rapidly Holly and the band were developing.
The Crickets could play hard-driving rock and roll.
They could move toward pop.
They could use unusual rhythms.
They could experiment with vocal harmonies.
And they were doing much of it with the compact instrumentation of a small guitar band.
A format that would dominate the next decade was already taking shape.
🎸 The Fender Stratocaster
Buddy Holly also helped place the Fender Stratocaster at the center of rock-and-roll imagery.
The guitar had been introduced only a few years earlier, in 1954.
Its contoured body, three pickups, and futuristic appearance looked radically modern compared with many older electric guitars.
Holly played one prominently during television performances and live appearances.
For teenagers watching at home, the image was unforgettable.
A Fender guitar, two other musicians, a drummer, and a song you had written yourself suddenly looked like everything required to start a band.
Plenty of young viewers decided to try.
📺 The Crickets on Television
Television accelerated the band’s rise.
Buddy Holly and the Crickets appeared on national programs including The Ed Sullivan Show, bringing their sound and appearance into American living rooms.
The visual impact mattered.
Holly did not fit the stereotype of the threatening rock-and-roll delinquent.
He appeared almost studious behind his dark-rimmed glasses.
Yet the music was undeniably part of the same youth revolution alarming parents and energizing teenagers.
That contrast made Holly strangely subversive.
Rock and roll did not have to look dangerous to change everything.
🎵 What Happened to the First Version?
The failed 1956 Decca recording did not disappear forever.
After the Crickets’ Brunswick version became a hit, Decca released the earlier Nashville version under the billing Buddy Holly and the Three Tunes.
Listeners could therefore hear two very different approaches to essentially the same song.
The comparison is fascinating.
The earlier recording reveals where Holly had been.
The Crickets recording reveals where he was going.
The song had not suddenly become better because the words and melody changed dramatically.
Holly had found the right sound for it.
That lesson extends far beyond this one record.
Sometimes a song is waiting for the performance that reveals what it really is.
🌟 Success Comes Quickly
After “That’ll Be the Day,” hit records followed at an astonishing pace.
“Peggy Sue.”
“Oh, Boy!”
“Maybe Baby.”
“Rave On.”
“Think It Over.”
“Early in the Morning.”
“Heartbeat.”
“It Doesn’t Matter Anymore.”
Holly’s nationally prominent recording career lasted only about a year and a half, yet the amount of durable music he produced during that period is extraordinary.
Some records were issued under the Crickets’ name on Brunswick.
Others appeared under Buddy Holly’s own name on Coral.
To listeners, the distinction was often less important than the unmistakable voice and guitar connecting them.
🕯️ A Career Cut Short
On February 3, 1959, Buddy Holly was traveling as part of the Winter Dance Party tour across the American Midwest.
After a performance at the Surf Ballroom in Clear Lake, Iowa, Holly chartered a small plane rather than continue on the tour’s uncomfortable bus.
Ritchie Valens and J.P. Richardson, known as the Big Bopper, also boarded the aircraft.
Shortly after takeoff, the plane crashed.
Holly, Valens, Richardson, and pilot Roger Peterson were killed.
Buddy Holly was only 22 years old.
The tragedy would later become embedded in American popular culture through Don McLean’s “American Pie,” which referred to the crash as “the day the music died.”
But Holly’s influence had already become too large to disappear with him.
🎸 The Crickets Continue
Jerry Allison and Joe B. Mauldin continued performing and recording as the Crickets after Holly’s death, with various musicians joining them over the years.
The band’s existence beyond Holly sometimes gets lost because his fame became so overwhelming.
Yet Allison in particular was a crucial collaborator.
He co-wrote songs, developed rhythmic ideas, and participated in the musical experimentation that defined the original group.
The Rock & Roll Hall of Fame eventually recognized the Crickets separately for their importance to the development of the rock-band format and their contribution to Holly’s groundbreaking recordings.
“That’ll Be the Day” belongs to Buddy Holly.
It also belongs to a band.
📚 Into the National Recording Registry
In 2005, the Library of Congress selected “That’ll Be the Day” for inclusion in the National Recording Registry.
The Registry preserves recordings considered culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant to the United States.
The selection recognized something listeners had understood for decades.
The song was no longer simply a successful 1957 single.
It had become part of the country’s recorded heritage.
The Library of Congress specifically noted both the earlier country-oriented version and the importance of the later Crickets recording, as well as the unusual degree to which Holly and the band created their own material.
🏆 The GRAMMY Hall of Fame
The Recording Academy had already honored “That’ll Be the Day” by inducting it into the GRAMMY Hall of Fame in 1998.
The recognition placed the record among historically significant recordings whose importance extends beyond their original chart performance.
By then, the song’s influence had been clear for decades.
Rock had moved through the British Invasion, psychedelia, hard rock, punk, new wave, alternative music, and countless other transformations.
The production techniques had changed.
Amplifiers became louder.
Songs became longer.
Studios became infinitely more sophisticated.
Yet the basic band standing behind “That’ll Be the Day” remained recognizable.
Guitars.
Bass.
Drums.
A singer.
A song.
🦗 The Blueprint for a Rock Band
It may be impossible to measure the Crickets’ most important influence precisely because their format became so ordinary.
A singer-guitarist at the front.
Another guitarist.
A bassist.
A drummer.
Band members involved in songwriting.
A memorable group name.
The model would soon appear everywhere.
The Beatles.
The Rolling Stones.
The Kinks.
The Who.
The Byrds.
The countless garage bands that formed after teenagers saw these groups and decided they could do the same.
Buddy Holly and the Crickets were not solely responsible for creating that structure, but they were among the most visible early examples.
Their influence spread partly because the formula seemed achievable.
🇬🇧 Why Britain Loved Buddy Holly
Holly’s influence on British musicians deserves special attention.
American rock and roll reached Britain during a period when young musicians were absorbing records by Elvis Presley, Chuck Berry, Little Richard, the Everly Brothers, Carl Perkins, Eddie Cochran, and other performers.
Holly offered something distinctive within that mix.
He seemed like the leader of an actual band.
He played his own guitar.
He wrote.
His music combined country, R&B, pop, and rockabilly without sounding exactly like any one of them.
His glasses made him look attainable rather than mythical.
For teenagers who would soon form the groups of the British Invasion, he provided a remarkably useful example.
“That’ll Be the Day” reaching No. 1 in Britain ensured that they heard him.
📻 A Record That Still Sounds Alive
Some records are historically important but sound unmistakably like museum pieces.
“That’ll Be the Day” retains something more immediate.
Part of that comes from its sparseness.
There are relatively few production elements to date.
The guitar still cuts cleanly through the recording.
The rhythm section still moves.
Holly’s vocal still possesses the quirky confidence that separated him from smoother singers.
The record captures a young band before rock had accumulated decades of conventions about what a rock band was supposed to sound like.
They were still helping establish those conventions.
That gives the performance a freshness that historical importance alone cannot explain.
🎬 From The Searchers to Rock History
The journey of the phrase itself is remarkable.
A line spoken by John Wayne in a Western enters the memory of two young Texas musicians.
They turn it into a song.
The first recording fails.
They record it again.
Record executives initially resist it.
A subsidiary label releases a small pressing.
Radio listeners discover it.
It becomes No. 1.
Teenagers in Britain hear it.
Members of the future Beatles record it.
Decades later, the Library of Congress preserves it as part of America’s recorded history.
Popular culture often develops through exactly these strange chains of connection.
A phrase travels from cinema into rock and roll and becomes something much larger than its origin.
✨ The Lasting Legacy of “That’ll Be the Day”
“That’ll Be the Day” was not the first rock-and-roll record, and Buddy Holly was not the first musician to combine country and rhythm and blues. Rock history rarely has such simple beginnings.
What the record did was crystallize several ideas that would become central to the music that followed.
A young musician could write his own song.
He could play it with a small band.
The band could develop its own identity.
The recording studio could help refine that identity.
A guitar did not need elaborate orchestration surrounding it.
Personality mattered more than vocal perfection.
And musicians who looked like ordinary teenagers could create sounds capable of traveling around the world.
Released on May 27, 1957, “That’ll Be the Day” began as a Brunswick single by a group whose name was largely unknown.
Within months, Buddy Holly and the Crickets were part of rock-and-roll history.
The song’s greatest legacy may be found not only in the famous artists who cited Holly as an influence but in every group of friends who subsequently picked up guitars, found a drummer, wrote a few songs, and decided to start a band.
Buddy Holly’s life was painfully short.
The idea contained inside “That’ll Be the Day” proved much harder to stop.
🔗 Related Articles
- Bill Haley: One of Rock’s Founding Fathers
- Billy Lee Riley’s “Flyin’ Saucers Rock ‘n’ Roll”: A Space-Age Rockabilly Classic
- The Voice of Ronnie Spector in the Golden Era of Music
- Elton Britt’s “Uranium Fever”: Soundtrack to America’s Atomic Gold Rush
- Music: Jazz, Rock & Roll, Crooners & Atomic Age Sounds
📚 Sources & Further Reading
- Library of Congress — “That’ll Be the Day” in the National Recording Registry
- Library of Congress — “That’ll Be the Day” National Recording Registry Essay
- Library of Congress — From the National Recording Registry: “That’ll Be the Day”
- Library of Congress — National Recording Registry Additional Information
- Rock & Roll Hall of Fame — Buddy Holly
- Rock & Roll Hall of Fame — “That’ll Be the Day” Sheet Music
- Official Charts — The Crickets: “That’ll Be the Day”
- GRAMMY Hall of Fame — “That’ll Be the Day”
